Medical associations sue FTC over Red Flags Rule
Just days prior to the latest enforcement deadline of the Red Flags Rule ("RFR"), medical and osteopathic associations sued the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) over the applicability of RFR's identity theft prevention requirements to their member organizations. FTC is to begin enforcement of the Rule on June 1, 2010. Among other claims, medical associations are seeking the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia to prevent the FTC from defining healthcare providers as "creditors" under FACTA. According to Health Data Management:
'The worst part is, I think, from a strictly ethical point of view, that you have to approach every new patient with suspicion about their identity,' said AMA spokesman Robert Mills. 'That violates every precept of the physician-patient relationship; the FTC is asking doctors to violate their role as trusted healer and counselor.'
The physician groups say that the rule requires them to set up identity theft prevention and detection programs, which aren't necessary, and said the FTC was 'arbitrary and capricious' in extending the application of the law to them. Also, the extension of the Red Flag Rule to doctors would do nothing to improve care, the physician groups say.
<...> According to the lawsuit, complying with the Red Flags Rule 'imposes significant burdens on physicians, particularly sole practitioners, and those practicing in small groups.'
Since most personal health information is already protected by HIPAA, including as modified by the HITECH Act, medical associations argue that the additional privacy safeguards imposed by RFR are simply not necessary. In addition, the American Bar Association succeeded in excluding lawyers from RFR requirements. Physicians argue that the exemption of lawyers should apply to healthcare professionals.
We will keep you posted regarding any developments in this case. However, until the court rules on the AMA's motion, healthcare organizations should remember the June 1, 2010 enforcement date for the Red Flags Rule. Click here for more information regarding the RFR requirements, but keep in mind the new enforcement date of June 1, 2010.
"Lawsuit: Red Flags Rule Violates Doctor/Patient Relationship," Health Data Management (May 21, 2010).